
We've all been getting makeovers from our stylist sister-in-law. I love it!
However stunned I was at the time with an unexpected breech presentation, a similar thought came to me as it had many years ago with vertex presentation. I wondered how many of the problems associated with breech birth are created rather than inherent to breech birth. The answer has led me to support women, who make an informed decision, to birth at home with their breech babies.Banks notes that midwives have largely lost their knowledge of physiological breech birth, since they often have only seen highly medicalized vaginal or cesarean deliveries for breech presentation. Her book seeks to categorize that knowledge so that women can continue to choose to give birth to their breech babies, rather than be delivered either vaginally or via cesarean. Her books is aimed towards midwives and expectant mothers, especially those facing a persistent breech presentation.
there are few certainties when it comes to weighing up the options for breech birth. Even with the Canadian multicentre international breech trial, published in 2000, paraded by some as delivering “the answer” to the breech conundrum (the answer apparently being to routinely offer caesarean section for breech, there is sufficient criticism of the study (see Chapter 8) to leave many feeling that the answer still eludes us. Overall the body of research we have often produces mutually conflicting data, and conclusions often state that studies of sufficient size and good enough design have not yet been carried out. The active, spontaneous approach to vaginal breech birth, described in more detail in Chapter 10 and espoused by some as the only safe way to conduct a vaginal breech birth is yet to be properly evaluated. Uncertainty should therefore be the uncomfortable though realistic norm in cases of breech.I will not attempt to summarize each chapter in this review—there is simply far too much information to cover—so instead I will list the chapters. This gives a good overview of the topics covered in Breech Birth.
The management of a vaginal breech birth is immensely controversial and particularly striking for the coexistence of starkly opposing views. Some argue that epidurals and forceps are essential to promoting safe vaginal delivery while others argue that this is actively harmful. The little evidence we have seems to suggest that less interventionist approaches permitting more spontaneous breech births are associated with better outcomes.Although I enjoyed both books, I would definitely recommend Breech Birth as the must-have of the two (in part because Waites thoroughly covers Banks', and many other midwives', perspectives on vaginal breech birth). I suggest that all midwives, physicians, doulas, and childbirth educators have a copy of Breech Birth on hand. Because it is published in the UK, it is not easy to obtain at a last minute notice—which is precisely when a woman, close to her due date, is trying to figure out what to do about a baby suddenly presenting, or refusing to turn from, breech. The book is written for a wide audience, from physicians, midwives, and medical students to childbirth educators and parents of breech babies. It is thorough in its research but still accessible to a lay audience without being overly simplistic.
I was the one who wrote you a few months ago looking for a Serbian midwife for her. She found one...but then...1. The midwife wasn't so great2. She had a strong night of pre-labor that spooked her doctor, who...3. Started talking about inductions, which raised her c/sec chances, esp. since she had fibroids.So we were all braced for the "inevitable" and she was scheduled to be induced on Tuesday morning (Serbian time), which was as much time as she could bargain from her doctor. But then, labor started Monday night! She went to the hospital, and little Adam Noah was born, all on his own. No complications, and he's beautiful, and she's fine.I hate to leave a story hanging, so pass along to your readers if you like. I sure hope her next birth is somewhere where she can have more options, though!Thanks againOh; Dad's blog entry about the baby, with pics:
"One third of all first-time cesareans are performed due to active-phase arrest during labor, which contributes to approximately 400,000 surgical births per year," said Caughey, who is affiliated with the UCSF National Center of Excellence in Women's Health. "In our study, we found that just by being patient, one third of those women could have avoided the more dangerous and costly surgical approach."If you'd like a copy of the full text, email me. The abstract is below:
Mrs Kaymak had been pushing for over an hour but had still not crowned. She seemed motivated and able to complete a successful vaginal delivery so it was decided to take her to theatre to perform an assisted vaginal delivery with the option of an emergency caesarean if necessary.Of course, we do not have the complete details of the situation, as is often the case with reports about infant deaths. However, the doctor never mentioned the baby being in danger. The woman's time limit had simply expired. And it was a short one at that--just over an hour! This was the mother's first baby, so that time limit seems especially out of place. It is not at all uncommon for a first-time mom to take 2+ hours to push her baby out.
I was 12 weeks pregnant when my NHS midwife asked me: 'Where would you like to have your baby?' Guessing she wanted me to choose between hospitals, I went for the nearest - King's College in South London. 'So,' she said, 'you don't want to be considered for a home birth?' I had thought home births were the exclusive preserve of West Country hippies. But ten minutes later I left my London clinic with 'home birth possibility' written on my notes. And to my surprise, Mum and Dad thought it was a great idea.But her Romanian mother-in-law was, to put it mildly, a tad anxious about the whole affair:
'I was born at home in the dugout during the Blitz,' said Mum. 'Your granny said giving birth was like shelling peas. Not like today - pregnancy is treated like an illness.' Dad, a retired livestock farmer from the Highlands, added: 'Aye, an animal will always take itself off to give birth; you need to be somewhere private. Don't ever forget you're a mammal. Mammals aren't designed to give birth in a bed.'
Mum wasn't exaggerating. As a Forties baby she was one of the last generation to be predominantly born at home, often minus pain relief, hot water or a bathroom. Change came with the creation of the NHS in 1948. Soon, more than half of babies were born in hospital; ambitious obstetricians wanted everyone under one roof and the Government agreed.
It was another day and night before Mara [her baby] arrived. I distracted myself watching movies, taking deep hot baths and eating to keep my strength up. I was glad to be at home. But my mother-in-law Elena, who had flown in from Romania, had other ideas. She hid upstairs, resisting the urge to call an ambulance, and spent 36 hours crossing herself, suffering sympathetic labour pains and shrieking that someone should give me an injection every time I let out a long moan.Mothers-in-law are great. But anxious MILs at my labor? No thanks! They would get a gentle push out the front door, with the assurance that I would call when the baby has arrived.